Eyeliner is one of those small details that completely changes a Sim's face, and the good stuff blends smoothly, sits right along the lash line, and doesn't clip into the eye at certain angles. In this roundup I've pulled together wings, tightlines, glittery looks, and a few bold statement liners for edgier makeovers. Everything reads cleanly in the CAS preview and works across a good range of skin tones, so let's get into the list.
All CC belongs to its original creators and is hosted on The Sims Resource. We link to each creator's TSR page and host nothing ourselves; previews are shown for reference with credit.
1. Calley Eyeliner – @msqsims
Calley is a soft, everyday liner that hugs the upper lash line without an aggressive flick, which makes it lovely for natural or minimal makeup looks. It keeps things subtle enough to layer under heavier eyeshadow, and the shape follows the eye rather than exaggerating it. That restraint is exactly why it works on so many face presets.
You get a tidy set of tones that lean toward soft blacks and browns, so it slots into casual and workday routines without shouting. It sits in the eyeliner slot for female Sims and stays base-game friendly, meaning no extra packs are needed to use it right away.
Created by MSQSIMS
2. Oh My Goth – Luna Eyeliner – @msqsims
Part of the Oh My Goth theme, Luna leans dark and dramatic with a heavy tightline and a defined wing that frames the eye boldly. It's built for gothic, alt, and moody makeovers where the liner is meant to be the focal point rather than a whisper.
The pigment reads as a deep, opaque black that holds up under close CAS zoom, and it pairs beautifully with smoky shadows and pale skin tones. If you're styling a witchy or nightclub Sim, this is the kind of liner that carries the whole look on its own.
Created by MSQSIMS
3. Lucy Spring Eyeliner – @msqsims
Lucy Spring is a fresher, lighter take on liner with a delicate line that opens up the eye instead of closing it in. The flick is gentle and rounded, which suits softer seasonal looks and Sims you want to read as sweet or youthful.
It's a good pick for spring and pastel-themed makeovers because it doesn't compete with brighter shadow colors. The shape is universal enough that it works across most face types without needing adjustment, and it stays base-game compatible.
Created by MSQSIMS
4. Ying Eyeliner – @msqsims
Ying gives you a sleek, elongated wing that stretches the eye outward for a more feline, dramatic finish. It's the type of liner that photographs well in gallery shots because the shape stays crisp and intentional rather than smudgy.
The line thickens gradually toward the outer corner, which is a nice touch that reads as hand-drawn rather than stamped on. It suits glam and editorial Sims especially well, and it layers cleanly over lid shadow without muddying the color.
Created by MSQSIMS
5. Flash Eyeliner – @msqsims
Flash is a bright, playful liner that leans into color rather than sticking to safe blacks and browns. It's aimed at costume, festival, and creative makeovers where a pop of unexpected pigment along the lash line is the whole point.
Because the shape stays fairly simple, the color does the heavy lifting, so it works well layered under matching or contrasting shadow. It's a fun choice for a Sim you want to feel expressive and a little bit theatrical.
Created by MSQSIMS
6. SETK Winged Eyeliner – @auradragon
SETK Winged Eyeliner is all about that clean, sharp cat-eye flick that so many CAS looks are missing. The wing extends at a flattering upward angle and stays razor-sharp even at close zoom, which is exactly what you want from a statement liner.
It works beautifully for glam, retro pin-up, and vintage-inspired Sims, and it holds its shape across different face shapes. The opaque black pigment keeps the line bold, so it reads clearly whether your Sim is in a close-up or a wider shot.
Created by Auradragon
7. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #26 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #26 from MELDEANNE brings that creator's signature soft realism, with a line that blends into the lash line naturally rather than sitting on top of it. It's the kind of liner that reads as makeup a real person would actually wear day to day.
The finish leans subtle and flattering, which makes it a reliable base layer for more detailed CAS looks. It's designed for female Sims and stays base-game compatible, so you can drop it into any save without worrying about missing packs.
Created by MELDEANNE
8. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #23 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #23 is a slightly softer, more diffused option in the MELDEANNE lineup, with a lived-in look that avoids harsh edges. It feels less like a costume and more like an everyday cosmetic, which is why it suits realistic and legacy-style gameplay.
The shape follows the natural curve of the eye and doesn't overpower lighter shadow colors. It's a versatile pick for Sims you want to look polished but not overdone, and it stays clean across a range of skin tones.
Created by MELDEANNE
9. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #24 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #24 sits between subtle and defined, giving you a touch more presence along the upper lash line without a dramatic wing. It's a comfortable middle-ground liner that works for both casual and slightly dressed-up looks.
The pigment stays smooth and even, and the shape reads believable rather than exaggerated. Like the rest of this creator's set, it's built for female Sims and slots neatly into the eyeliner category with no extra requirements.
Created by MELDEANNE
10. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #25 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #25 carries a bit more definition than the softer numbers in the series, with a cleaner edge that makes the eye pop in portraits. It's a nice option when you want your Sim's makeup to register clearly without going full glam.
The finish stays natural enough for everyday use while still adding structure to the eye. It pairs well with neutral shadows and works across teen through elder, making it flexible for whole-household makeovers.
Created by MELDEANNE
11. Nari Eyeliner – @msqsims
Nari is a delicate, precise liner with a thin line that emphasizes the eye shape without adding bulk. It's ideal for Sims you want to look refined and understated, and it sits well under more colorful or graphic shadow.
The subtlety here is the selling point, since a thinner line reads as effortless and polished. It stays base-game compatible and works cleanly across most face presets, so it's an easy everyday staple to keep in your CC folder.
Created by MSQSIMS
12. Harlequin Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Harlequin Eyeliner is a bold, theatrical piece built for costume and character looks rather than subtle daily wear. The design leans into a dramatic, playful shape that suits clowns, performers, and fantasy Sims who need their makeup to make a statement.
Because it's such an expressive liner, it works best on Sims where the face is meant to be eye-catching and stylized. It's a great tool for storytelling saves where you're building distinct, memorable characters.
Created by EvilQuinzel
13. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #22 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #22 keeps things soft and wearable, with a gentle line that flatters the eye without dominating it. It's the sort of understated liner that works quietly in the background of a fuller makeup look.
The natural finish makes it a strong base layer, and it holds up nicely at close CAS zoom without looking pixelated or harsh. It's built for female Sims and stays base-game friendly, so it's easy to slot into any save.
Created by MELDEANNE
14. Sparkling Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Sparkling Eyeliner adds a shimmery, glittery finish along the lash line for looks that need a little extra sparkle. It's perfect for party, festival, and glam Sims where a subtle glint catches the light in gallery shots.
The glitter effect stays tasteful rather than overwhelming, so it reads as a fun accent instead of a mess. It layers well over regular shadow and gives an instant lift to any celebratory or night-out makeover.
Created by EvilQuinzel
15. Python Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Python Eyeliner brings a bold, textured look inspired by snakeskin patterning for genuinely unusual makeover ideas. It's a striking choice for fantasy, mystical, and creature-inspired Sims where you want the eyes to feel otherworldly.
This is a statement liner rather than an everyday one, so it shines on characters built around a specific dramatic theme. If you enjoy edgy, unconventional CAS creations, it's a fun way to push a look somewhere unexpected.
Created by EvilQuinzel
16. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #21 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #21 offers a clean, natural line with just enough definition to shape the eye nicely. It sits comfortably in the realistic side of MELDEANNE's collection, making it a dependable everyday option.
The finish avoids harsh edges and blends smoothly along the lash line, which keeps it looking believable up close. It works across teen through elder female Sims and needs no extra packs to use.
Created by MELDEANNE
17. Heartbreak Eyeliner – @willeekmer
Heartbreak Eyeliner takes a graphic, decorative approach with little heart-inspired accents that make it feel playful and romantic. It's aimed at expressive, alt, and e-girl style Sims who want their makeup to have a distinct personality.
The design reads clearly in CAS thanks to the bold shapes, and it pairs well with matching blush or glossy lips. It's a lovely pick for Valentine's-themed shoots or any Sim built around a soft-but-edgy aesthetic.
Created by Willeekmer
18. Clover Eyeliner – @msqsims
Clover is a fresh, tidy liner with a clean line that opens up the eye in a flattering way. It leans natural, which makes it a comfortable choice for Sims you want to look put-together without heavy glam.
The shape follows the eye's natural curve and stays crisp under close inspection. It's base-game compatible and slots neatly into everyday makeover routines, layering well beneath neutral or soft shadow colors.
Created by MSQSIMS
19. MELDEANNE – EYELINER #20 – @meldeanne
Eyeliner #20 gives you a soft, realistic line that reads as genuine cosmetic rather than costume makeup. It's a strong base option for detailed CAS looks where you want the liner to support rather than steal focus.
The blended finish keeps things natural at close range, and the shape flatters a wide range of face presets. Designed for female Sims and base-game friendly, it's an easy addition to any everyday makeup rotation.
Created by MELDEANNE
20. Wave Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Wave Eyeliner puts a creative twist on the classic wing with a flowing, curved line that feels artistic and distinctive. It's a great choice for Sims where you want the eye makeup to feel a little more designed and intentional.
The shape stays crisp and clear in CAS, so the wave detail actually reads instead of getting lost. It works nicely for editorial and creative makeovers, adding an unexpected flourish that sets a Sim apart.
Created by EvilQuinzel
21. Chan Eyeliner – @msqsims
Chan is a clean, precise liner with a subtle flick that adds structure to the eye without going overboard. It's flattering on softer face shapes and works especially well when you want a polished but understated finish.
The line stays neat and even, reading believably up close. It's base-game compatible and suits female Sims across a broad age range, making it a versatile daily option for household-wide makeovers.
Created by MSQSIMS
22. Eyeliner N15 – Kalinda – @pinkycustomworld
Kalinda from PinkyCustomWorld's numbered series is a refined liner with a smooth, well-defined line that shapes the eye elegantly. This creator's makeup tends to look high-quality and cohesive, and this piece fits right in with that reputation.
The finish balances natural and glam, so it works for both casual and dressed-up Sims. It sits cleanly along the lash line and holds its shape at close zoom, making it a dependable everyday-to-evening option.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
23. Oh My Goth – Witchcraft Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
This Oh My Goth Witchcraft liner leans fully into dark, mystical makeover territory with a bold, dramatic shape. It's built for witchy, occult, and gothic Sims where the eyes are meant to look powerful and a little haunting.
The heavy pigment reads as deep and opaque, pairing beautifully with smoky shadows and pale complexions. If you're styling a spellcaster or a moody alt Sim, this is exactly the kind of statement liner that sets the tone.
Created by EvilQuinzel
24. Jess Eyeliner – @msqsims
Jess is a soft, everyday liner that keeps the eye looking natural and awake without any dramatic flair. It's a reliable base layer for Sims you want to read as effortlessly pretty rather than heavily made up.
The line stays thin and clean, following the eye's shape gracefully. It's base-game compatible and works across a wide range of face presets, so it's easy to drop into casual makeovers and legacy gameplay.
Created by MSQSIMS
25. Eyeliner N10 – Alice Glitter – @pinkycustomworld
Alice Glitter adds a sparkling, shimmery finish that catches the light for glam and party-ready looks. The glitter detail sits along the lash line and gives an instant festive lift without overwhelming the rest of the face.
It's a lovely choice for night-out, holiday, or celebration Sims, and it layers well over both neutral and bold shadow. The shimmer reads clearly in gallery shots, which makes it fun for posed, dressed-up screenshots.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
26. Lia Pride Eyeliner – @msqsims
Lia Pride Eyeliner celebrates Pride with a colorful, expressive design that's perfect for festive and inclusive makeovers. The bright palette makes it a joyful choice for Sims you want to feel bold, proud, and full of personality.
The colorful line reads clearly in CAS and pairs well with equally vibrant looks. It's a great pick for Pride-themed shoots or any Sim built around a cheerful, colorful aesthetic that doesn't shy away from making a statement.
Created by MSQSIMS
27. [CyFi] Alternate Reality Eyeliner – @willeekmer
![Sims 4 [CyFi] Alternate Reality Eyeliner by Willeekmer](https://res.cloudinary.com/o1pbdl5q/image/upload/v1785142927/tsr/mfboq0hau3ii1ssmjmcj.jpg)
The CyFi Alternate Reality liner is a futuristic, sci-fi inspired piece designed for cyberpunk and otherworldly Sims. The graphic, techy shape makes it a standout for alien, android, or neon-city makeovers where ordinary liner just won't cut it.
It reads boldly in CAS thanks to its distinctive design, so it shines on characters built around a specific futuristic theme. If you love building out sci-fi worlds, this is a fun way to give a Sim an instantly non-human edge.
Created by Willeekmer
28. Natural Liner – @theplumbobfairy_
Natural Liner does exactly what its name promises, offering a soft, barely-there line that enhances the eye without looking like obvious makeup. It's ideal for realistic gameplay and Sims you want to read as fresh-faced and effortless.
The subtle finish blends into the lash line smoothly and holds up well at close zoom without looking harsh. It's a great everyday staple that layers under heavier looks or stands alone for a clean, minimal finish.
Created by ThePlumbobFairy_
29. Infernal Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Infernal Eyeliner is a bold, fiery-themed liner built for demonic, fantasy, and dramatic character looks. The intense design suits Sims where the eyes are meant to feel dangerous and commanding rather than soft or subtle.
It's a strong statement piece that carries a whole makeover on its own, pairing well with dark shadows and edgy styling. For occult and villain Sims, it's a fun way to give a face genuine menace and presence.
Created by EvilQuinzel
30. Eyeliner N6 Lil Touch – @pinkycustomworld
Lil Touch is a minimal liner that adds just a whisper of definition along the lash line. As the name suggests, it's meant to be a light finishing touch rather than a bold statement, which makes it perfect for natural looks.
The thin, clean line keeps the eye looking soft and open without any heaviness. It layers beautifully under shadow or stands alone for a low-key finish, and it works across a wide range of face presets.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
31. Beverly Eyeliner – @msqsims
Beverly is a polished, defined liner with a shape that flatters the eye and adds a touch of elegance. It sits comfortably between natural and glam, making it versatile enough for both daytime and evening looks.
The line stays crisp and even at close zoom, reading as intentional and well-drawn. It's base-game compatible and suits female Sims across a broad age range, so it's an easy pick for whole-household makeovers.
Created by MSQSIMS
32. Melody Eyeliner – @msqsims
Melody offers a soft, graceful liner that shapes the eye gently for a refined, feminine finish. It leans natural while still giving enough definition to make the eye stand out in portraits and gallery shots.
The smooth line blends nicely along the lash line and pairs well with soft or neutral shadow. It's base-game friendly and flexible across face types, which makes it a comfortable everyday staple for realistic gameplay.
Created by MSQSIMS
33. Mia Eyeliner – @playerswonderland
Mia from PlayersWonderland is a clean, well-crafted liner with a shape that enhances the eye without going heavy on drama. This creator's makeup tends to be high-quality and cohesive, and Mia fits that dependable, everyday-glam feel.
The line reads believably at close zoom and works across a range of skin tones and face presets. It's a versatile option that dresses up or down easily, making it a solid addition to any CAS makeup rotation.
Created by PlayersWonderland
34. Katrin Eyeliner – @msqsims
Katrin is a defined, elegant liner with a subtle flick that adds structure to the eye in a flattering way. It's a strong choice for Sims you want to read as put-together and stylish without heavy costume makeup.
The line holds its shape cleanly and reads clearly in CAS, so the definition actually registers. It's base-game compatible and works nicely across female Sims of different ages, making it an easy everyday-to-evening pick.
Created by MSQSIMS
35. Olivia Eyeliner – @msqsims
Olivia gives you a soft, natural line that opens up the eye and keeps things looking effortless. It's a gentle, wearable liner that suits realistic gameplay and Sims you want to feel understated and pretty.
The thin line follows the eye's curve smoothly and stays clean at close zoom. It layers well under more colorful shadow and works across a wide range of face presets, making it a reliable everyday staple.
Created by MSQSIMS
36. Hilary Eyeliner – @msqsims
Hilary is a polished liner with a clean, defined shape that adds a touch of glam without overwhelming the face. It sits comfortably in the everyday-to-evening range, which makes it a flexible option for lots of different looks.
The line stays crisp and even, reading as intentional and well-drawn up close. It's base-game friendly and works across female Sims of various ages, so it's an easy pick to keep in your regular makeup rotation.
Created by MSQSIMS
37. Valerie Eyeliner – @msqsims
Valerie offers a refined, elegant line that flatters the eye and leans slightly toward glam. It's a lovely choice for dressed-up Sims and gallery shots where you want the eye makeup to look polished and deliberate.
The shape stays clean and holds up nicely at close zoom, pairing well with both soft and bold shadow. It's base-game compatible and versatile across face presets, making it a dependable everyday-to-evening staple.
Created by MSQSIMS
38. Saya Eyeliner – @msqsims
Saya brings a clean, precise liner with a shape that adds structure and a touch of drama to the eye. It's a great option for Sims you want to look stylish and defined without going into heavy costume territory.
The line reads clearly in CAS and stays sharp even at close zoom, so the definition holds up well. It's flexible across skin tones and face types, which makes it an easy addition to a wide variety of makeovers.
Created by MSQSIMS
39. UghWhateverMom – Twiggy (Eyeliner) – @ughwhatevermom
Twiggy is a retro-inspired liner that nods to the iconic '60s mod look with its distinctive graphic shape. It's perfect for vintage, pin-up, and themed makeovers where you want the eyes to feel bold and nostalgic.
The design reads clearly in CAS and pairs beautifully with pale lids and dramatic lashes for the full retro effect. If you love styling era-specific Sims, this is a fun way to nail that unmistakable vintage vibe.
Created by ughwhatevermom
40. Eyeliner Clown – @alifya
Eyeliner Clown is a playful, theatrical piece built for costume and character looks rather than everyday wear. The bold, expressive design suits clowns, performers, and stylized Sims who need their makeup to be genuinely eye-catching.
Because it's such a statement look, it shines on characters where the face is meant to be dramatic and memorable. It's a great tool for storytelling saves and creative makeovers built around distinct, larger-than-life personalities.
Created by Alifya
41. K EYELINER – LANELOVEY – @lanel0vey
K Eyeliner from lanel0vey is a clean, modern liner with a shape that enhances the eye in a fresh, contemporary way. It leans toward the everyday-glam side, making it a versatile pick for a wide range of makeovers.
The line stays crisp and reads clearly at close zoom, blending smoothly along the lash line. It works across different skin tones and face presets, so it's an easy, dependable option to slot into your regular CAS routine.
Created by lanel0vey
Final Thoughts
Eyeliner is such a quick way to give a Sim personality, so grab a couple of naturals for daily wear and one bold statement liner for your more dramatic characters. Big thanks to these creators for keeping the CAS makeup catalog so rich.