Goth makeup is where a Sim's whole attitude lives, so the good CC has to read clearly on the face without turning muddy up close. I look for crisp eyeliner edges, deep pigmented lips, and eyeshadow that layers with lenses instead of fighting them. This roundup pulls together dark, dramatic looks from trad goth face paint to sharp winged liners and vampy glosses. Here are the pieces worth grabbing.
All CC belongs to its original creators and is hosted on The Sims Resource. We link to each creator's TSR page and host nothing ourselves; previews are shown for reference with credit.
1. TRAD GOTH Makeup (FACEPAINT) – @necrogypsy
This sits in the face paint category rather than the standard makeup slot, which means it stacks with your usual eyeliner and lips without overwriting them. That layering trick is exactly what a full trad goth look needs, since you can build the batwings and cheek detail on top of everything else. It's a smart base for anyone who wants the whole subculture aesthetic in one placement.
The design leans into classic trad goth references with bold graphic shapes rather than soft smoky blending. It photographs well in CAS close-ups because the lines stay sharp instead of dissolving into pixel mush, and that clarity is half the reason a look like this actually lands in-game.
Created by necrogypsy
2. Harlequin Eyeliner – @evilquinzel
Harlequin liner takes its cue from the diamond, painted-mask look, so it's a step beyond a plain wing and into something more theatrical. It's the kind of piece that turns a plain Sim into a stage performer or a moody club regular the moment you apply it. If you like your goth with a touch of circus, this is the one to reach for.
The shape works best paired with a strong lip and simple lashes so the eyes stay the focal point. Because the pattern is graphic and symmetrical, it reads cleanly even at a distance in gameplay, which not every detailed liner manages to pull off.
Created by EvilQuinzel
3. Maria Eyeliner – @maruchanbe
Maria eyeliner has a soft, hand-drawn quality that feels less like a stamp and more like something actually painted on, which suits a romantic goth look beautifully. The wing curves rather than shooting out in a hard flick, so it flatters rounder eye shapes and keeps things a little dreamy. It's an everyday goth liner more than a costume piece.
It pairs naturally with the matching Maria eyeshadow from the same creator, and the two were clearly built to sit together. Used alone it still holds up, giving you a versatile base you can dress up with lenses and a deeper lip whenever the mood calls for it.
Created by MaruChanBe
4. Maria Eyeshadow – @maruchanbe
This eyeshadow is the companion to the Maria liner, and the two really do shine as a set. The blending is soft and diffused rather than a hard block of color, which gives that smudged, lived-in look goth makeup does so well. It settles into the crease naturally instead of floating as a flat sticker on the lid.
Expect a range of moody swatches you can match to lenses or a lip, and the muted palette means it plays nicely with both pale and deeper skin tones. It's the kind of shadow you'll keep in rotation because it never competes too loudly with the rest of a face.
Created by MaruChanBe
5. Zayla Eyes – @msqsims
Zayla eyes give you a set of striking lens colors built for that otherworldly, not-quite-human stare goth looks love. The iris detail is what sells them, with rings and flecks that catch the light instead of reading as a solid dull circle. They make a Sim feel like they've got a story behind their eyes.
Because they sit in the eye color slot, they play well with any liner or shadow you layer on top. Try them with a pale face and a dark lip for a proper vampire feel, or tone it down for a subtle daytime goth who's just a little uncanny.
Created by MSQSIMS
6. Clover Eyeliner – @msqsims
Clover eyeliner keeps things clean and versatile, with a defined line that suits Sims who want goth energy without going full theatrical. It's precise along the lash line and flicks up just enough to lift the eye, making it one of those reliable everyday picks. You'll reach for it far more often than the flashier options.
The neutral, wearable shape means it layers under bolder face paint or stands alone for a minimalist look. That flexibility is exactly why a well-made basic liner earns its spot in a collection full of dramatic statement pieces.
Created by MSQSIMS
7. Elia Lipstick – @msqsims
Elia lipstick brings a smooth, saturated finish that holds its color instead of going patchy at the edges of the lips. Deep goth shades live or die on how solid they look up close, and this one keeps the pigment even from center to cupid's bow. It's a confident, put-together lip rather than a soft stain.
The finish leans satin, so it catches a subtle sheen without looking wet or glossy, which suits a more sophisticated goth. Pair it with the creator's own liner and lenses and you've got a coordinated face pulled from a single maker's set.
Created by MSQSIMS
8. Luci Eye Color – @maruchanbe
Luci eye color offers a set of moody, atmospheric iris shades that lean into the darker end of the spectrum. The detailing gives depth to the eye rather than a flat wash of color, so even deep tones still read as living eyes and not painted glass. They're a great foundation for a haunting overall look.
Because these sit in the eye slot, they stack freely with liner and shadow, giving you room to experiment. Drop them under a heavy smoky eye for full drama, or let them do the work alone with bare lids for a quieter, unsettling stare.
Created by MaruChanBe
9. Rose Eyeliner 02 – @remussirion
Rose Eyeliner 02 is the follow-up version, refining the original with a slightly different wing and line weight. It gives a soft romantic-goth feel, the kind of liner that suits a Victorian-inspired Sim as much as a modern one. The curve is gentle rather than aggressive, so it flatters a lot of eye shapes.
It layers beautifully under heavier eyeshadow or stands on its own for a cleaner day look. Having both this and the original in your folder means you can pick the exact wing that suits each Sim's face, which is a nice little luxury.
Created by RemusSirion
10. Soft Vamp Lipgloss – @sagittariah
Soft Vamp lipgloss does exactly what the name promises, delivering a glossy, light-catching finish over a vampy base color. The shine gives lips a plump, hydrated look that softens the harshness a matte goth lip can sometimes carry. It's a lovely middle ground between dark and pretty.
The gloss reads especially well in close-up shots where you actually see the highlight sitting on the lip. Wear it with softer lenses and a light smoky eye for a goth look that feels approachable rather than severe, perfect for a younger or more romantic Sim.
Created by Sagittariah
11. Rose Eyeliner – @remussirion
This is the original Rose eyeliner, a soft winged style with a hand-painted quality that feels delicate rather than harsh. The line hugs the lash and lifts into a subtle flick, giving eyes definition without shouting. It's an elegant base for a romantic goth or vampire look.
It sits happily under bolder shadow or lenses, so it works as a foundation layer as much as a standalone. Because the wing is understated, it flatters a wide range of eye shapes and never overwhelms a delicate face.
Created by RemusSirion
12. Souleater Lipstick – @comaron
Souleater lipstick has a name that tells you everything about its energy, delivering a deep, devouring dark shade with attitude. The pigment is rich and opaque, the sort of lip that anchors an entire goth face on its own. It's made for Sims who want their mouth to be the statement.
The finish stays solid across the lips without thin spots, which is crucial for the darkest shades where any gap shows instantly. Team it with pale skin and sharp liner and you've got a striking, gothic-glam result in seconds.
Created by comaron
13. Kiro Eyeliner – @maruchanbe
Kiro eyeliner offers a bold, graphic line that leans more edgy than romantic. The shape has a modern sharpness to it, making it a great fit for a punk-adjacent or club goth Sim rather than a soft Victorian one. It brings instant confidence to the eyes.
It holds its crisp edge well in-game, so the drama doesn't smudge into a blur when the camera gets close. Layer it over a smoky shadow for full intensity, or wear it clean against bare lids to let the line itself do all the talking.
Created by MaruChanBe
14. Oh My Goth – Eyeliner 41 – @remussirion
Part of the popular Oh My Goth series, Eyeliner 41 is one of many numbered liner options from this prolific creator. Having a whole set numbered like this means you can find the exact wing shape and thickness that suits each Sim without settling. This one lands in the everyday-wearable end of the range.
The line is clean and defined, giving eyes structure without overpowering the rest of the face. Because it's part of a matched collection, it pairs seamlessly with the series' shadows, lips, and lenses for a fully coordinated goth look.
Created by RemusSirion
15. Oh My Goth – Eyeliner 45 – @remussirion
Eyeliner 45 is another entry in the Oh My Goth liner lineup, offering a slightly different flick and weight from its neighbors in the set. The value of a numbered collection like this is choice, letting you match the liner precisely to a Sim's mood and eye shape. This one carries a touch more drama than the softer options.
It stays sharp and legible in CAS, which matters for a liner meant to be a focal point. Slot it in alongside the series shadows and lenses and everything reads as one intentional face rather than a patchwork of mismatched CC.
Created by RemusSirion
16. Oh My Goth – Ghost Eyes – @remussirion
Oh My Goth Ghost Eyes go all in on the supernatural, giving Sims a pale, haunting stare that suits vampires, spirits, and the truly undead. The washed-out effect is exactly what you want for a Sim who's meant to look drained of life. They completely transform the mood of a face.
Sitting in the eye slot, they layer freely with the series' heavy liners and smoky shadows. Pair them with a dark lip and sharp winged liner and you'll get a genuinely eerie result that stands out from the usual colored-contact CC.
Created by RemusSirion
17. Oh My Goth – Coenzyme Eyeshadow – @remussirion
Coenzyme eyeshadow brings a smoky, blended look to the Oh My Goth collection, with soft edges that melt into the lid rather than sitting as a hard block. The diffused finish is flattering and gives that lived-in smudge goth eyes do so well. It's a versatile base for building up drama.
Because it's designed alongside the series liners and lenses, everything coordinates without clashing. Deepen it toward the outer corner with a matching liner and you've got a rich, moody eye that works for daily wear or full gothic glam.
Created by RemusSirion
18. Oh My Goth! – Lips – @anonimux-simmer
These Oh My Goth lips bring a range of dark, saturated shades from Anonimux Simmer, giving you plenty of moody options in one download. The color stays even and opaque, which is essential for the deepest goth tones where patchiness ruins the effect. It's a solid workhorse lip for the collection.
The variety of swatches means you can match the lip to different outfits and eye looks without hunting down separate CC. Whether you want near-black, deep berry, or a muted mauve, having them bundled keeps your goth faces coordinated and quick to build.
Created by Anonimux Simmer
19. Oh My Goth! Vesper Eyeliner – @kareemzisims
The Vesper eyeliner from KareemZiSims brings a sharp, confident wing to the Oh My Goth family. The line has a modern edge that suits a club or fashion goth as much as a traditional one, and it lifts the eye with a clean upward flick. It's a striking choice for a bolder Sim.
It holds its crisp shape close up, so the drama doesn't turn to blur in CAS. Layer it over one of the series' smoky shadows for full intensity, or wear it against a clean lid to keep the whole face focused on that decisive line.
Created by KareemZiSims
20. Oh My Goth – Blair Eyeshadow – @pinkycustomworld
Blair eyeshadow from PinkyCustomWorld adds a smoky, blendable option to the Oh My Goth range with soft gradient edges. The shadow settles into the crease naturally rather than sitting flat on the lid, giving eyes real depth. It's a flattering pick that works across a range of skin tones.
It's built to coordinate with the wider series, so pairing it with matching liners and lenses is effortless. Build it darker for a full gothic evening look, or keep it sheer for a subtler everyday goth that still carries plenty of mood.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
21. Oh My Goth – Solute Eyeshadow – @remussirion
Solute eyeshadow is one of RemusSirion's contributions to the Oh My Goth collection, offering a moody blended finish that reads soft rather than harsh. The gradient work gives the lid dimension, so it looks like carefully applied makeup instead of a color sticker. It's a dependable base for layering.
Because it shares the series' palette, it slots neatly beside the matching liners, lips, and lenses. Deepen the outer corner with a compatible liner and you've built a rich smoky eye that anchors the whole gothic face.
Created by RemusSirion
22. Oh My Goth Monochrome Lenses – @caroll91
These Oh My Goth Monochrome Lenses from Caroll91 strip color right back for a stark, greyscale stare that suits the darkest looks. The monochrome approach gives Sims an unsettling, drained quality that colored contacts can't match. They're ideal for vampires, wraiths, or anyone meant to look otherworldly.
Sitting in the eye slot, they layer under any liner or shadow from the series without conflict. Pair them with a heavy smoky eye and a near-black lip for a genuinely haunting result that stands apart from brighter fantasy lenses.
Created by Caroll91
23. Oh My Goth | Gothic Hairline | N3 #GOTH – @cosimetic
This Gothic Hairline N3 from cosimetic tackles a detail a lot of goth looks forget, refining the edges of the hairline for a cleaner, more realistic frame around the face. Good hairline CC makes wigs and styles sit more convincingly, which matters a lot in close CAS shots. It's a subtle but genuinely useful addition.
As part of the Oh My Goth series it's designed to complement the dramatic makeup rather than compete with it. Used alongside the collection's liners and lips, it quietly pulls the whole face together and makes everything above the brows look more polished.
Created by cosimetic
24. Oh My Goth – Nosferat Lipstick – @remussirion
Nosferat lipstick leans hard into the vampire theme its name suggests, delivering a deep, dramatic lip built for the undead. The pigment is rich and fully opaque, holding solid across the lips so the darkest shades never look thin or patchy. It's a proper statement mouth for a gothic Sim.
It coordinates with the rest of the Oh My Goth collection, so matching it to the series lenses and liners is simple. Set it against pale skin and a sharp winged eye and you've got instant classic-vampire drama.
Created by RemusSirion
25. Oh My Goth – Eyeliner 42 – @remussirion
Eyeliner 42 continues RemusSirion's numbered Oh My Goth liner set, offering yet another wing shape to choose from. The beauty of the numbered range is precision, letting you fit the exact line thickness and flick to each Sim's face. This one sits comfortably in the wearable, everyday zone.
It renders cleanly in CAS so the line stays defined instead of smudging. Because it belongs to the same coordinated series, it pairs effortlessly with the matching shadows and lips for a face that reads as one deliberate look.
Created by RemusSirion
26. Oh My Goth – Hypocotyl Lipstick – @remussirion
Hypocotyl lipstick brings another deep, moody shade to the Oh My Goth family with a smooth, even finish. The color stays solid across the lips, which is exactly what the darker end of the goth palette needs to avoid looking blotchy. It's a confident lip that anchors a whole face.
As part of the coordinated series, it matches easily with the collection's liners, shadows, and lenses. Wear it with a bold smoky eye for full drama, or against a cleaner face when you want the lip to carry the entire look.
Created by RemusSirion
27. Oh My Goth – Pentagram Eyes – @remussirion
Pentagram Eyes push the occult theme right to the front, embedding a symbol into the iris for a Sim who's fully committed to the aesthetic. It's a bold, unmistakably themed choice that works for witches, cultists, or dramatic supernatural characters. These are not subtle, and that's entirely the point.
Because they sit in the eye slot, they still layer with any liner or shadow you add on top. Keep the rest of the face relatively simple so the symbol reads clearly, and you'll have a striking, storytelling detail no ordinary lens can offer.
Created by RemusSirion
28. Oh My Goth – Noir Eyeshadow (M) – @pinkycustomworld
Noir eyeshadow from PinkyCustomWorld comes marked for masculine frames, which is a welcome touch since goth makeup for male Sims is harder to find. The blend is smoky and diffused, giving the lid depth without looking overly done. It's built to flatter a masculine face shape.
Being part of the Oh My Goth series, it coordinates with the collection's male-compatible liners and lips too. Layer it up for a dramatic guyliner-adjacent look, or keep it sheer for a subtle smudge that reads goth without going theatrical.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
29. Oh My Goth – Cadell Eyeliner (M) – @pinkycustomworld
Cadell eyeliner is another masculine-tagged piece from PinkyCustomWorld, filling the real gap in goth liner made for male Sims. The line is clean and defined with a shape that suits a masculine eye rather than being repurposed from a feminine wing. That thoughtful design makes a genuine difference.
It pairs directly with the matching Noir eyeshadow for a coordinated male goth look from a single creator. Use it for a subtle rimmed eye or build it bolder for full club-goth energy, depending on how dramatic your Sim wants to be.
Created by PinkyCustomWorld
30. Oh My Goth – Catabolic Eyeshadow – @remussirion
Catabolic eyeshadow adds another smoky option to RemusSirion's Oh My Goth lineup, with soft gradient edges that blend cleanly into the lid. The diffused finish gives eyes a lived-in depth rather than a flat block of pigment. It's a flexible base you can build up or keep sheer.
Sharing the series palette, it sits comfortably beside the matching liners and lenses. Deepen the outer corner with a compatible liner for a rich evening eye, or wear it lightly for a subtler goth that still carries real atmosphere.
Created by RemusSirion
31. Oh My Goth – Eyeliner 39 – @remussirion
Eyeliner 39 is one more in the numbered Oh My Goth liner set, giving you yet another wing to pick from in the collection. The numbered approach is genuinely handy because you can dial in the precise flick and thickness each Sim needs. This one carries a slightly softer curve than the sharpest options.
It stays crisp in close-up so the line never dissolves into a smudge. Because it's part of the coordinated series, it slots in seamlessly with the matching shadows and lips for a face that looks intentionally styled.
Created by RemusSirion
32. Oh My Goth – Derivative Lipstick – @remussirion
Derivative lipstick brings another deep, dramatic shade to RemusSirion's Oh My Goth collection with a smooth, even finish. The color holds solid across the lips, which is essential for the darkest tones where any patchiness immediately shows. It's a reliable statement lip for a gothic face.
It coordinates with the rest of the series, so matching it to the collection's liners and lenses takes no effort. Set it against pale skin with a sharp eye for classic goth drama, or soften it with a lighter smoky look for something more wearable.
Created by RemusSirion
33. Oh My Goth – Sharp Winged Eyeliner – @bill-sims
The Sharp Winged Eyeliner from Bill Sims is exactly what the name promises, delivering a crisp, aggressive flick that makes a bold statement. This is the liner for a Sim who wants a razor-sharp cat eye that dominates the face. The precision of the wing is its whole appeal.
It renders cleanly in CAS so the sharp edge stays sharp rather than blurring up close. Wear it against a clean lid to let the wing be the focus, or layer it over a smoky shadow for a heavier, more intense gothic eye.
Created by Bill Sims
34. Oh My Goth | Gothic Eyeliner | N88 – @cosimetic
Gothic Eyeliner N88 from cosimetic brings a distinctive, detailed liner design to the Oh My Goth series with real artistic flair. The shape goes beyond a plain wing, adding decorative elements that give the eye a more elaborate, styled finish. It's a great choice for a Sim who wants their eye makeup to feel considered.
The line holds its detail cleanly in close-up so the intricate work actually reads in-game. Pair it with the collection's coordinated shadows and lenses to build a fully realized gothic look with a genuinely artistic edge.
Created by cosimetic
35. Oh My Goth-Esmere Lipstick [HQ] – @benevita
![Sims 4 Oh My Goth-Esmere Lipstick [HQ] by Benevita](https://res.cloudinary.com/o1pbdl5q/image/upload/v1785146221/tsr/vlj34xp6xexg41kf2slx.jpg)
Esmere lipstick from Benevita is flagged as HQ, meaning it's optimized for the high-quality mod and looks crisper and more detailed under that lighting. That extra polish shows in the smooth, realistic finish on the lips. It's a lovely pick for anyone who plays with HQ enabled.
The shade suits the darker goth palette while keeping a natural texture rather than a flat painted look. As part of the Oh My Goth collection, it matches easily with the series' liners and lenses for a coordinated, high-detail face.
Created by Benevita
36. Oh My Goth Morose Lip Gloss – @caroll91
Morose Lip Gloss from Caroll91 closes out the collection with a glossy, light-catching finish over a moody base color. The shine gives lips a fuller, hydrated look that softens the severity a matte goth lip can carry. It's a nice way to add dimension to a dark mouth.
The gloss really comes alive in close-up where you see the highlight sitting on the lip. Wear it with softer lenses and a light smoky eye for a goth look that leans romantic and approachable rather than harsh, rounding off the set beautifully.
Created by Caroll91
Final Thoughts
That's a serious goth arsenal, from sharp winged liners to haunting lenses and vampy glosses, so mix and match until each Sim's face tells its own dark story. Huge thanks to these creators for keeping the Oh My Goth aesthetic alive.